Rated 4 out of 5 by SPGReview99999999 This hotel has very spacious rooms.
Room was spacious & bed was comfortable. Ordered room service my first night of my stay & they got the order wrong - I left the tray & plates outside my door expecting the night crew or someone to retrieve it but it was still there in the morning at 7am when I left. I also tried to order again the next night but got no answer from the front desk or dining. I ended up just walking down to the restaurant to have dinner since I couldn't get an answer. Banquet staff were very helpful during our event at the hotel, overall our stay was great.
April 2, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Bear91 Noisey elevator
The dinging of the elevator kept us up most of the night.
April 7, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by MikeA Avoid, the place is a joke
The rooms are old, tired and dirty. The staff simply don't care, the valet takes 30 minutes to get your car. As a Platinum memeber, I was given access to the club lounge, when I visited the lounbge to get breakfast one morning at 8 AM, they were already out of food and the attendent told me that they had no plans of replenishing. Avoid this place.
June 1, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by pBOB Extremely clean
Very clean, neat and well run hotel. I would not hesitate to stay there again.
April 4, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Bridedad Best Wedding Venue in Columbus!
We hosted a New Year's Eve 2011/2012 wedding for our daughter Jessica & son-in-law Nick, here! it was simply fantastic! The staff was friendly, the service and food was tremedous. Executive Chef Jonathan and Chef Jason prepared a spectacular meal for our 320 guests. The meals were delivered on time, the food was delicious and served hot! The service led by Vernon & staff was tremendous. Our guests raved about the venue, the food, the rooms, the staff, the lighting, the food, bar & restaurant service....all great. Our biggest treat was working with Chris & David., Catering & Banquet leads and the entire Sheraton 'A' Team! Sheraton: You made this Father of the Bride very happy & proud...Welcome to Columbus, Sheraton...and Happy New Year!
January 14, 2012
Rated 3 out of 5 by lilysmimi Why could I smell everything from the next room?
We stayed here because we were in town for a concert at Columbus Commons and this was right next door. I loved the location and the room was nice but every time we were in our room we kept smelling a very strong sweet smoky smell and we couldn't figure out what was going on. Finally, when we were trying to go to sleep but couldn't because our eyes and nose were burning, we tracked down the smell. The people in the next room were either burning incense or smoking something and then burning the incense to cover it up and the smell and probably the smoke was coming through the adjoining door. Even though it was shut and locked we were still getting the smell. While I don't really care what people in the other rooms are doing, I was rather perturbed and upset that the seal between the doors was so bad that whatever my neighbors were doing was keeping me from sleeping. I called to the front desk to complain and I also said something to the front desk when I checked out but they both seemed rather unconcerned that this happened. I don't normally splurge on one of the better hotels when I am just spending one night but I was with my daughter and we wanted to make it a relaxing mother daughter event and I was disappointed that this happened and we had to put up with this. One a good note, the bed was very comfortable and the room was nice otherwise.
June 25, 2012
Rated 1 out of 5 by aw28 The worst experience ever
I stayed in this hotel for the half marathon event going on in columbus this weekend and from beginning to end my experience was beyond disaster. To start with I was told over the phone when I booked that I would have a room with a microwave and a fridge, that I would have free internet access, and that a late check out due to the marathon would be no problem. While arriving at the hotel, I was unaware of the parking situation in Columbus so I was a bit confused about what I needed to do. I had one staff member outside tell me while I was waiting behind several vehicles that valet parking was free for those staying for the marathon. At this point I had already been through 2 hours of hunting for parking places through surrounding garages and it was getting late. When the staff member got to me to take my car he told me it was a $30 charge, completely different than what I was just directed. Because I had already been waiting for so long and needed to make the marathon dinner, I was just going to pay it. He then told me i couldn't pay with a credit card and I would have to go get cash. At this point I was already ready to call the hotel and cancel my stay, but I didn't. I found a parking spot at the columbus commons parking area that a random person outside told me about. While checking in I was there was only one room option available regardless of what I was guaranteed over the phone, so I had no fridge or microwave for food options. By the time I got checked into the hotel it was later than the marathon dinner event they were holding. The phone in my room didn't work so every time I needed something I had to use my cell phone. I called a staff member who said he would bring me a menu and that he could have the kitchen make a pasta dish for me if I go down to the lounge. I went into the lounge and they told me they don't do special dishes and I have to order what is offered at those times on their menu. It was almost 1030 pm and I hadn't eaten dinner yet. I couldn't leave the hotel out of fear that I would run into loss of parking spots again because of the number of people in town for this event. From here I spoke to a lady at the front desk who gave me a catering menu of delivery options. I went back upstairs to my room and called and they were closed. It took everything to not call the manager and ask for my money back. I wasn't in marathon event mode anymore and was about to skip everything and drive back home. I spoke to another gentleman who gave me pizza places who will deliver. I tried to log onto my laptop to look at pizza menu when it asked me to pay for this service. So when i called the front desk she told me this service is only available to certain rooms. Once again I had been given false information from several different staff members. I called pizza hut and ordered something simple. The guy who delivered the order called me when he arrived to the hotel and told me that the people at the front desk were not letting him come up to the room. They even commented to me when I let them know how my night has been so far- that it isn't their fault I didnt make it in time for the runners dinner. But my wait for valet parking and the run around from employees outside had a huge part to deal with how late I was able to check in. I was beyond angry at this point. I'm a very patient person but I didn't know how much more I could handle from this hotel. I went to bed after eating with the hopes that the next day would be a new day. After the marathon event I came to my room and called the front desk just to confirm that I was okayed the late checkout. I didnt want to deal with interuptions while getting cleaned up after the race. The gentleman I spoke with was very rude to me and asked who I talked to because they never allow late check outs and I should be charged for this. I told him the lady who said this was ok and he said ok fine but we never do this just for future reference and hung up on me. While I was in the shower I had someone knock on my door several times. I'm assuming it was housekeeping and they weren't informed of my late checkout. So it wasn't just a fluke that the first night was horrible for me- the whole experience at this hotel was bad from beginning to end. The cost of this hotel is not cheap compared to others. To not have a complimentary breakfast, free internet service, and deal with all of the complications of food ordering, nonworking phone in the room, no fridge or microwave- this stay wasn't even close to worth what I paid. I'm leaving this lengthy review so everyone can see the details of what happened. All of the staff members at this hotel need to be on the same page because I was given a different story the whole time. Employees should know what food options are available for guests who aren't from around there and whether parking is free, and they should see what you were guaranteed on the phone while booking the hotel room. I will never ever stay here again. I will still be calling about this experience as well. I stay in hotels on a frequent basis and this was the worst experience I have ever had!!
May 6, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by MommaB Family Visit
Spent Valentine's weekend in Columbus to visit our son. Hotel was great! We had a double room. We were surprised at how spacious the room and the bathroom were. Very comfy bedding. Only drawback was the slowness of the Wifi in the room. Never used it in the lobby. Location was good. Walking distance to Arena district and many downtown areas. Drove to Easton - another great place to visit while in Columbus. Had a great time!
February 19, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Judygee Surprised
After reading a less than flattering review, I was expecting to put up with what ever I had to for a short time. What a pleasant surprise.
The staff were bright, cheerful, helpful and courteous. The hotel is lovely. My room was spotless, and comfortable. The only shortcoming was no refrigerator or microwave. Restaurant, wonderful, inexpensive by today's standards.
August 7, 2012
Rated 2 out of 5 by Poncho Memorable experiences - mainly bad ones
Here are my top three
3. Valet tries to open my Toyota with a Nissan key and when it does not tries to tell me that its not my car - very smart
2. Fitness has a great view through the windows but no water, towels or gym wipe more frequently than I expect
1. This is a jewel - My wife and I return to the room to a stink of cigarette smoke (in a supposedly non-smoking property) - its spewing in through the ventilation system.
Thankfully, there was John at the bar to take good care of us during dinner - appreciate your hospitable manner John - thanks
But I would rather pay less to stay in the Sheraton Suites - at least I get what I expect
May 8, 2013
Rated 4 out of 5 by Judge441 Columbus 2011
The typical Sheraton experience... clean, quiet rooms, cordial staff, everything I have come to expect.
My only complaint was the television. Bad picture, few channels, the sound jumped from barely audible to being too loud in a single click, and the menu function did not work. I hardly had time to watch it anyway, so it was not an issue.
I would strongly consider booking at this property for future visits to the area. The staff makes the difference, and they were terrific.
October 25, 2011
Rated 4 out of 5 by turboD Clean, enjoyable, best for weekday business travel
I actually attempted to pay more to avoid staying here because the negative reviews posted here, but could find no availability. So my wife & I celebrated our first anniversary here, and thoroughly enjoyed our experience. The facilities are nice, our room was clean & had a decent view, the staff was friendly & helpful, and the bed was PHENOMENAL!
The location was nice, except that in the immediate neighborhood there were virtually no restaurants open over the weekend. Plan ahead for places to eat and plan to drive if you stay during a weekend. Otherwise you'll end up paying a hefty premium for the average food & mediocre service at The Plaza restaurant onsite.
Contrary to some reviews here, there were no hidden fees (sure, you can pay for Wi-Fi, but it's not a secret).
To summarize, we had a blast, the room was comfortable, the service was friendly & prompt, and there are much better restaurants around but you'll have to drive to them.
October 15, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by LB2566 The Staff is Great !!!!!!
Just the Best clean rooms
May 15, 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 by joey68 Disappointed
Never stayed in downtown Columbus before so I was totally disappointed about the ever not so helpful staff at the hotel. Didn't know where to go for parking if I didn't want to valet. Ended up driving around for 15 minutes in circles to end of being parked at the bottom of the Commons.The valet attendant ended up helping me carry my bags up 3 flights of stairs to check in. When I got to the desk, the girl that was there was totally rude. I am hard of hearing and I asked her to repeat herself and she said, "never mind". So I had no idea about valet parking, Wi-Fi, or even where to eat . Once I did get into my room it was very nice, spacious and clean. I unpacked went downstairs to ask directions from the front, again, I felt that I was inconveniencing them by giving me directions to the Federal Court House which were not helpful. I ended up asking the shoe repair man that is in the building who was very nice. Later night I had to get a cab and again talked to the front desk and she said go out front and catch one and I cannot type the tone she used. In the morning I'm in the shower at its 8:00am and there is a knock on my door. It was housekeeping wondering what time I planned on checking out that morning. I was appalled! For the price of the room I had different expectations I would of liked to stay and additional day but not there.
March 8, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by Fleedog Wasn't Worth The Price
Paid an exorbitant price for an average room. Went to bed and had a leaking ceiling dripping off the headboard. Notified staff upon checkout and they didn't seem to care. There was no mention of a reduction in the room price. Wont be back!
March 5, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by cookie4 Paper thin walls. Stained bedding
Had read previous reviews but figured it couldn't be that bad. I was wrong. Could hear my neighbors till 5:30 in the morning. There were four drunken guys with a cooler and a love for MMA fighting which they emmulated till the wee hours, throwing themselves against the wall and the adjoining door. They were so verbally abusive to each other we were uncomfortable complaining because they would know who it was. We complained in the morning to the front desk who could care less. The lobby was filled with High School Students who were unsupervised and the hotel personel did nothing to help the situation. Luggage was everywhere and kids were laying all over the furniture and computers. Entrance was thru the valet parking which made it awkward.
March 23, 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by Levi1825 Lots of bad stories to share
When we arrived, the heating in the room didn't work. Instead to switching us to a different room, the staff said maintenance would come to the room. Two calls and an hour later, maintenance arrived, found the problem, and turned on the heat -- which then could not be turned off, so the staff finally switched us to a different room (11:00 PM). The next day, housekeeping never serviced the room. The morning after next, the fire alarm went off at 5:30 AM, telling everyone to leave the hotel, which we did. The reason, it turned out, was not a fire, but a water problem that resulted in no hot water. So everyone at the conference we were attending went through the day without having showered. I could go on -- food service running out of coffee and eggs at breakfast, staff looking zoned out, This hotel is a disaster.
March 25, 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 by Weekend13 Don't Arrive Late in the Evening
We made our reservation about a month before our stay and when we arrived, they did not have the room we reserved available. We were told- it's first come, first served. My children were not too happy with sleeping on the sleeper sofa, when we had reserved a room with 2 double beds. Towels had holes in them. Shelves in the bathroom had quite a bit of dust on them. Had to wait about 45 minutes for linens for the sleeper sofa.
April 8, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by YSW1 Great Hotel
I had a block of 25 rooms over a weekend (2 nights). I was extremely impressed. Maggie Butler (Conv. Service Manager) had a "will do" attitude to make sure everything runs smoothly. The front desk staff were extremely nice, helpful & out to please. The Hotel is new renovated & beautifully decorated. The rooms are beautiful. Housekeeping was very attentive & helpful to all our needs. I highly recommend this Hotel.
June 27, 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by Newt Didnt get the room that I reserved.
I reserved a room with a king bed. When I arrived (at night) I was told that check-in is at 3pm and my room had been given away. I suppose next time I will reserve any room available, show up at 3pm and take over the best room at the hotel.
Also, the water heater went out and our water was brown and cold. Good thing we didnt drink to much of it in the middle of the night.
March 26, 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 by jfbrown56 You need improvements!
* Friendly staff
* When I checked in, the person told me I ordered a handicapped room. Not true.
* Not enough electrical outlets. There was only 1 outlet at the working desk area, and I had to move the desk to get to it.
* 2 pieces of the molding at the base of the wall were off and laying on the floor - gives the appearance that the place is deteriorating.
May 8, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by susie47 Comfortable
This hotel has a great downtown location and the bed was outstanding. I do have a suggestion for the Manager....your Valet parking has a sign stating parking is $17.00 for all day...when we checked out I saw the charge was $23.00. I also read this same complaint on Trip Advisor which I contribute too..I asked to speak with the manager (unavailable) someone from the desk explained that all night parking was $23...I was trying to make the point that all day means a 24 hour day...I don't care if the parking is $23...but I do care that you are playing with words to get money...people don't like that....so if you want to keep a good image on Trip Advisor I suggest you change your signage.
April 7, 2013
Rated 2 out of 5 by Henry The hotel was beautiful however the room was dirty
The room was dusty-bathroom countertop had approx one onch of dust on it as did all of the furniture; the carpet needed vacuumed; the ice bucket had something(food?) on it and it was unusable; the view from our room was great but the window was disgusting and we weren't a le to enjoy it; i thought plastic cups in the room was tacky for a four-star hotel
May 6, 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 by Michele Disappointed
Reserved two rooms with 1 card, paid with another and they charged both cards. No hairdryers, parking is a pain and expensive. It was a non-smoking hotel, however, people were smoking. Hallways reeked of smoke.
The valets were very nice and helpful though.
May 20, 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 by Redneck Not the Best Sheraton
Food was not great and dining room could not accomodate many people. My room was not cleaned until after 6 pm. Staff seemed inexperienced. I have stayed at many Sheraton's and this was below par.
March 16, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by Pam56 Stacy is wonderful
We stay at this hotel once a month and it is our favorite. Stacy at front desk is a gem and so accommodating! Always so attentive to needs.
Hotel is lovely and location is perfect.
July 7, 2013
Rated 2 out of 5 by Traveler Poorly Maintained Facilities
While the staff was friendly, the room was filthy. The bathroom was not clean. The carpets were filthy, the chair at the desk actaully still had a former guests hair band on the seat.
April 5, 2013
Rated 2 out of 5 by ABC123 Needs improvement
TV Remote in the room was not working; cordless phone was not user-friendly; bathroom was cleaned swiftly, leaving hair from previous guest on the floor and in the tub. Gross.
May 22, 2013
Rated 3 out of 5 This hotel is decent for the price and in a good location.
I was not impressed with the cleanliness of the room or the restaurant but the hotel itself was very nice. Parking not so great.
April 22, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by Dee4444 Hotel met my expedctations
Enjoyed my stay with the hotel. Received courteous service from varied staff. Liked the casual yet somewhat upscale atmosphere.
March 11, 2013