Rated 4 out of 5 by VAtraveler12 Great Stay
I really enjoyed my stay. The staff was excellent! I thought the hotel location was great as well and it is convenient to many NYC attractions.
My one negative - There was a lot of mold around the tub/shower.
July 21, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by iadsea Not ready for prime time...
This hotel is not ready for prime time:
Descent location, newly renovated rooms of good size for NYC
1. Business center closed, no advanced notice
2. No platinum recognition at check in, no ask for amenity preference
3. No glasses in bathroom, only plastic cups
4. Internet requires log in every 5 minutes after 1st day (may not be common)
For the $415/night I paid with a corporate discount, the hotel was an awful value. Choose a different SPG hotel in NYC.
October 11, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by Twinkletoes22 Had everything we needed for NYC!
Stayed at this hotel for 4 nights on a mother daughter city break! Anything we needed was sorted straight away! The room was big, cool and clean! The view of the Chrysler building was a lovely bonus!! The staff were friendly and helpful! We even managed to be given a limo for our return to the airport which was a great end to a great trip! When definitely recommend this hotel and can't wait to come back and stay again!
July 19, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Katy1066 Mostly amazing
Overall, the hotel was beautiful and the staff was amazing. There were a few issues, however. First was a few housekeeping issues in the room. There are some stains by the toilet paper holder that are suspicious and should be cleaned and the rain cap and other products on the bathroom counter had something stuck to them that a previous guest had left. Additionally, when I ordered eggs benedict for breakfast one morning, the eggs weren't cooked enough and I had a puddle of runny whites on my plate. The room service manager was amazing and personally made sure that my breakfast the next day was perfect. So overall, great reviews but with a few little housekeeping things. I wouldn't say that it's a relaxing hotel in that it was mostly hustle and bustle but thats 42nd street. You don't come to NYC for peace and quiet.
July 18, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Sunbox11 Great Location. Nice Room. Tiny Bathroom.
When I arrived, I got in the Platinum/Gold member line. They did not acknowledge my status or provide me with the opportunity to select my welcome gift. When I got to the room, I called down to find out if my membership status entitled me to free in-room internet for my stay. Typically, internet is complimentary to Gold members and above. It was only at that time that they acknowledged my status and that I could select a welcome gift, either free internet for my stay or complimentary Starpoints. I chose the internet and was told they would notate my account to prevent charges. I then went and checked out the bathroom. It was so small that the door hit the toilet. You could not sit on the toilet with the door open and the door would literally scrape across the toilet or your legs if you tried to open it. I have never been in a room with a more uncomfortable bathroom. Since we were in town for a wedding, we had many events which required us to get ready in the room. I certainly would not recommend the room, simply because of the bathroom. The room, itself, was nice and spacious enough for NY, with a great view of the Empire State Building nearby and the water in the distance. The hotel was nice enough and the location was optimal, but the bathroom was hard to forget. Also when we checked out, they had charged me for the internet anyway. When I explained that it should be complimentary and why, the front desk did remove the charges without hassle. However, it should not have been charged in the first place. After over 10 years of membership and loyalty, we weren't made to feel like special, dedicated SPG guests.
July 10, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by tf4pitt Excellent
The hotel was immaculate. Staff was wonderful!!!
July 21, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by matto232 Unhappy with treatment and quality of service
at the Westin for three nights this past weekend, the first of which was in a suite. I requested an early check in and that another platinum member, who was sharing the room with me and arriving earlier, to have his name added to the reservation. Both were promised but neither happened. The suite was not ready until a quarter of 8 on a Friday night, a night on which we had diner plans. I myself waited in the lobby for over an hour waiting on the room receiving little explanation and poor estimates of when the room would actually be ready. I was only offered a drink ticket after my third or fourth inquiry into what the holdup was. We also asked for cups to be brought up to our room - took over a hour - and for an extra toothbrush - we had to wait, and then were given toothpaste. A lot of this I could have overlooked if I didn't feel as though a large portion of the staff I had to deal with were so rude. I have always enjoyed excellent service at SPG properties but, this was unacceptable.
May 28, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by mrchaos great location
This hotel is well placed in NYC. Staff was friendly and helpful. Checked in during a really hot day. The room's AC wasn't working and at 10:4 pm, within 10 minutes of calling the front desk an engineer knocked on our door and fixed it!
July 18, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by DRV123 SPG lack of Recognition
They don't acknowledged the SPG status. Didn't get the SPG floor, extra points or free internet. They check you in like if they were selling metro tickets....
July 18, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by Twinn2013 Love the location but not quite impressed about the associate.
Was staying for Superbowl weekend, Jan 29 - Feb 3, 2014. My stay overall was wonderful, the room was big enough for New York standard hotels but was not really pleasant with most of the associates in front desk and lobby. I agreed with most of the reviewers here about how poor customer service skills from front desk and the greeter associates in the lobby.
The greeters should have a friendly smile and willingness to help in any way would go a long way with hotel guests entering the lobby, instead, most of them was just talking each other and careless about guests walking to lobby without smile or even bother saying "Good afternoon, Welcome to Westin Grand Central New York".
Also my friends and I realized that the greeters was looking up at us from head to toe and judge us from our appearance every time we walked in or out the lobby without smile and without greeting us at all, Maybe because of my race?
I believe every guest staying in Westin hotels or with any Starwoods Hotels & Resorts deserve to receive an EQUAL service level from the hotel, regardless of their appearance, race, age, sx orientation and religion
For Westin Grand Central New York GM :
Please watch surveillance camera periodically in the main lobby, and please pay attention to the greeter and front desk staffs, you will find out why most of SPG elite members staying in your hotel complaining for. Also, I hope your hotel participate for Make a Green Choice Program soon to save our environment.
February 4, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by CPam Great Hotel
Hotel was better than expected. New rooms, very friendly staff all around. Bar was a nice place to unwind. Loved the Starbucks! Parking was a bit expensive, but on par for the area. Window opened which was a nice feature.
July 18, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by crafty5529 Great Place
Great place to spend time away from life. Nice to jump a cab or ride subway right out the front door. Easy arrivals from trains.
July 17, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by latearriver Does what it says on the tin
Not a particularly spectacular building- more functional. However, it is very well located, decent value for the area, and has comfortable Westin beds. I have never been double booked (unlike certain other SPG hotels around there), and it is always efficient. My only quibble is that the automated express checkout is a little unreliable and it sometimes takes a while to get the final folio out of them
July 15, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by eksnewyork Less together than usual
I've stayed at this hotel and it seems something was out of whack with housekeeping. When I got there there was no soap, no laundry bag, no lotion, etc. On day two nobody ever cleaned our room at all. I called for things but they were slow in coming. I mention this because the week before my uncle stayed there and nobody cleaned his room for 3 days so clearly something is not right. Get it together!
July 14, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by spgspgspg Your elevators were terrible
Several of your elevators stopped at every floor or every few floors even though there was no one waiting to get in.
Since I was on the 39th floor, the elevator rides were ridiculously long.
July 15, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by bj827 Below Westin Stnadards
Maid did not show up until almost 4 pm to clean room. Also, time to change the mattresses to newer heavenly beds.
July 15, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by Ludbear Excellent Hotel - Central Location
Excellent hotel and attentive staff. The comfort of the bed and linens are second to none - just amazing. The only issue was that the room could have been cooler despite the a/c being set for the lowest temperature.
July 14, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by sukigirlfriend valet parking
price was outrageous and i was not told beforehand so i could make an informed decision
July 15, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Andrew97 Smooth Stay
Staff, location and overall experience was an
A+, Highly recommend for any business or personal visit.
June 30, 2014
Rated 2 out of 5 by MHHKR Does not meet Westin's level of proper guest service.
Location is decent
Nicely renovated/clean rooms
Service, service, service
October 15, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jeffrey71 Very nice hotel
Been to New York twice. By far the better of the two hotels we've stayed at
July 14, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by TheTravelCritic Great Facilities...but
So how does a Westin Hotel have no SPG check-in. No Sign, No Recognition, just a long line to wait in to check in. Very Disappointing from this SPG Lifetime Platinum Customer. On the upside, the hotel was very nice. Room was very comfortable, bed was great, Bathroom very nice. Even allowing for the "New York" that comes out in some folk in NY, the staff starting with the front desk was very kurt, short, not quite rude but close. Clearly they had something more important than me to deal with and I wasting their time. Overall A great location and good hotel. Get the staff some training and get an SPG checkin line and this would have been a five star stay.
January 21, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by AtlantaBrian Service was excellent
I was a little concerned about the front desk service after reading several reviews, and my trepidation was completely unfounded. I found the staff to be extremely pleasant and helpful at each step of the process. I arrived early and they offered to call me when my upgraded room was available. After a little while I decided that because I had meetings I wanted to take from my room that I would forgo my upgrade and they got me into a room immediately. Everyone was very pleasant.
June 23, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by Tony118 Worst Staff of any Starwood Hotel
I spend a lot of time staying at Starwood hotels and for the most part, I'm usually pretty happy. Never - and I mean never - have I encountered worse staff or felt so unwelcome in a Starwood hotel before.
1. Upon arrival, and with considerable luggage, three porters were standing outside the hotel doing nothing. Not one offered any assistance whatsoever and were quite happy for me to struggle on my own after travelling for more than 20 hours
2. The check-in process took a very long time and it seemed the front desk was very understaffed with only two agents manning the desk
3. On the first morning, I noticed my credit card had been double billed for my stay, so I approached the front desk to query the matter. As I asked for clarification, the agent treated me with absolute contempt, trying to intimate I was stupid, while saying "why don't you listen?". It was only after I asked for the Duty Manager's intervention that the issue was resolved and I was shown to be right, but an agent trying to demean a guest in such a way can never be excusable
4. The attendant at the continental breakfast counter on the first few mornings of my visit was offensively rude. On trying to place my order, on two occasions, the attendant rudely interjected and shouted "so is it coffee or tea?" and then slammed the items down on the counter when they were ready, pointing at the bill to which he shouted "sign"
5. On two mornings I was unable to have breakfast as the service simply took too long. On one morning, it took more than 10 minutes for my order to be taken, and on the other, no one had come to take my order so I had to leave. While I found your a-la-carte breakfast staff pleasant, you appear to have too few of them during busy periods in the morning. On the days I did have time for breakfast, the whole service could take up to an hour which is very unsuitable in a busy city like New York City
6. Bath towels on some days were nothing short of threadbare
7. The worst thing - I wrote directly to Edward Maynard- the General Manager of this hotel about my experience. I never received an acknowledgement or any response to my complaints. Clearly the poor service comes right from the top.
Starwood has much, much better hotels in New York City. There's no reason to stay here.
November 4, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by nicole26 Enjoyed our Stay
The hotel was perfect for our vacation, allowing easy access to both uptown and downtown via the Grand Central Station subway terminal. Rooms were well-situated, newly remodeled, and larger than expected for NYC standards. Upon arrival we received an SPG upgrade to a high level room with a lovely view of the Chrysler building. The only downside is that the building has older windows that allowed some of the outside noise to be heard during the nights/early morning. This is somewhat expected in NY, though, and not an issue if staying on the weekends. We would definitely stay here again! Great drinks in the lobby bar/restaurant, too!
July 15, 2013
Rated 4 out of 5 by MB060953 NY trip
over priced but very nice
July 11, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by DockT A few fumbles
We've stayed at the Westin before and had great service. This time there were a few fumbles. We accepted a room with a pull out couch for my kids because it had a great view. We asked to have linens delivered before we went out to watch the fireworks and when we got back hours assistance
refrain from mentioning competitors or the specific price you paid for the hotel
do not include any personally identifiable information, such as full names
Example: This hotel has great features
Your Review*later- no linens. So we called down. We got sheets, but no blankets. So we called down. Also, we asked if it was possible to have 4 spoons to eat some ice cream we bought. We were told, of course, but had to call down a second time to have them delivered. I was surprised. That said, we had a great trip and the valet staff was great.
July 7, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by naomi39 Love this hotel
We stay at your hotel every year and its always great. The beds are amazing and the location is great. The only thing that would be better is if there was a breakfast offered either in a voucher or something else from the eating area.
Other then that its fantastic!
July 9, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Siesta Thon Hotel has great features
Very good. The best place for hat you want on Manhatten.
July 10, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by cstl Needs improvement
Air conditioning does not work well. Rooms are not very quiet.
July 10, 2014